When The College of Nurses Comes Calling

A patient, or more accurately, the family member of a patient has threatened to report an emergency nurse I know at another hospital to the College of Nurses of Ontario.

This is serious business. The College of Nurses is the professional regulatory body of nurses. Its mission is to “protect the public’s right to quality nursing services by providing leadership to the nursing profession in self-regulation.” According to its website, the College “regulates nursing to protect the public interest and sets requirements to enter the profession, establishes and enforces standards of nursing practice, and assures the quality of practice of the profession and the continuing competence of nurses.” In other words, the College receives complaints not only from patients but employers*, disciplines nurses for breaches of the Standards of Practice, and has the power to fine nurses and suspend or revoke licences to practice.  The College’s complaints and disciplinary procedures are generally adversarial, punitive, Byzantine and laborious, and the most trivial complaint against a nurse will result in legal bills running in the multiple thousands of dollars, even if it never goes before a disciplinary hearing.

As a rule, the College of Nurses is generally feared, if not loathed, among Ontario’s nurses. To be fair, those coming before disciplinary hearings usually (but not always) deserve it: they’ve committed some violation the Standards so egregious, so gross, they deserve to be tossed out of the profession. These usually involve sexual or physical abuse, or some other violation of trust. Then there are the corner cases that often don’t make it to disciplinary hearings, and which I think generally have to do with clinical performance: a missed medication, not properly assessing a patient, not providing proper nursing care.  My friend’s case falls into the latter category. She misjudged and misassessed a patient’s condition, and the patient nearly died as a result. Awful enough, for both the patient and the nurse. But she was also besieged by patients, her department was hideously busy, and she was in a role in which she was inexperienced.

She will get spanked for this if the family member carries out his threat.

Unfortunately, the College of Nurses rarely, if ever, addresses underlying issues. The nurse is always and utterly to blame at all times. This is called accountability. In many hospitals, however, when a sentinel event occurs — an event in which a patient was harmed because of some sort of human or systemic error — an inquiry into the root causes of the event is done. What were the contributing factors?  So, to give a very common example, when a medication error occurs, it’s not as simple as the “nurse gave the wrong drug.” Sometimes procedure isn’t followed. Maybe the nurse didn’t do the Five Rights and the Three Checks.** But maybe the medication vial looked similar to another right beside it in the med room. Maybe the concentration of the medication changed. Maybe the names of two medications had similar sounding names. (This happens a lot.) Maybe the work environment was cluttered and noisy. Maybe the nurse had too many patients with similar-yet-different medication regimens. And so on. The point is not to assign blame, or even to dodge responsibility. The point is to prevent it ever happening again.

I hope my colleague makes out okay. She’s a good nurse with a long and spotless record. But she tells me that her finances are such she can’t afford $10,000 in legal expenses, and she may have to leave the profession if she gets the dreaded Registered Letter. I get the accountability thing. But I’m not clear that forcing good nurses out of the profession is in the public interest either.

__________

*Employers — hospitals, nursing home, whatnot — of course are never assumed to be acting in bad faith. Because employers, presumably, always treat their nurses with fairly, and with justice and respect.

**Five Rights: Right Drug, Right Dose, Right Time, Right Route, Right Patient.

Three Checks: Check the drug when taken from the shelf, when pouring it, and before putting it away again.

, , , , ,

  1. #1 by Art Doctor on Tuesday 20 July 2010 - 2001

    This is a shame.

  2. #2 by Maha on Tuesday 20 July 2010 - 2115

    Sometimes I think nursing should be defined by the motto – “all the work, none of the respect”

  1. Tweets that mention When The College of Nurses Comes Calling « Those Emergency Blues -- Topsy.com

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: