Bigoted Jackasses Need Not Apply

Some Canadians and, I’m guessing, few Americans will be familiar with the case of Bill Whatcott. This is the nurse who distributed flyers to Regina households describing gay men as “predatory,” “filth,” and “pedophiles.” Understandably, some Regina residents were upset, and complained. His anti-gay speech drew the wrath of the Saskatchewan Human Rights Commission, where he was fined $15,000 for promoting hate.  Whatcott appealed up through the system, and the Supreme Court of Canada agreed to hear the case yesterday.

I’m not so much concerned here about the free speech aspects of this case.  To my mind, anyway, he certainly has the right to be offensive, no matter how disgusting or grotesque he might be, and I hope the Supreme Court finds in his favour — free speech isn’t just for the people we agree with.  The interesting part for me is that Bill Whatcott was an LPN; the Saskatchewan Association of Licensed Practical Nurses stripped his licence because he was circulating hate literature, and also because he was picketing a Planned Parenthood clinic.* (SALPN’s decision was reversed on appeal, on free speech grounds.  It doesn’t appear Whatcott ever returned to nursing.)

My question: does being a through-and-through bigot disqualify you from being a nurse?  For a few reasons unrelated to the free speech issue, I’m thinking yes.

Providing safe and competent nursing care and building therapeutic relationships requires objectivity on the part of the nurse, trust and empathy. Can you be objective and empathetic if you’re (unjustly) thinking your gay patient is a filthy child predator — Whatcott’s language — and further, is damned to Hell?  And can a patient ever trust his nurse in providing care, knowing his nurse effectively despises him and wishes him ill?  The ethical principle of justice demands nurses treat all patients equally.  It’s difficult for me to see how this is possible if you’re a bigot, even if you think you can compartmentalized your nursing and your bigotry into separate slots. In any case, being a nurse does require a higher ethical and moral standard.  Bigots should consider another profession.

Lastly, a thought experiment: if you think a person’s view of homosexuality is strictly her own opinion, and doesn’t affect the provision of nursing care, what if the nurse was a member of the Ku Klux Klan and distributing literature on miscegenation?  Is this, in practical terms, any different from what Bill Whatcott did?

__________

*SALPN’s website doesn’t give the particulars of this case, but one of its grounds for discipline is “tend[ing] to harm the standing of the profession.”

, , , , , , , , ,

  1. #1 by Maha on Thursday 20 January 2011 - 0243

    I think we always bring ourselves and experiences to the table when we see patients – the important thing is not letting those experiences be a barrier to providing competent and compassionate care. This guy cannot do that if he thinks that a significant percentage of the population he treats are ungodly deviants.

  2. #2 by Jenn Jilks on Friday 21 January 2011 - 1204

    Well said, again, woman!
    I agree. Like I told my students: ‘You can think I’m an effin’ bitch, but you can’t say it.

    Healthcare practitioners *may* hold particular political, social views, but they are not allowed to act on them. We are judged by our actions.
    Every patient should be treated equally, no matter culture, values, traditions, and this lobbying indicates a less than pure soul.

    Many people with such issues (seems mental health to me, judging by the vitriolic language) escalate their actions. he felt he wasn’t being heard and had to go public.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: